RON MALY HAS BEEN WATCHING THE PARADE GO BY FOR A LONG TIME. THIS IS ONE OF HIS WEBSITES.

Friday, May 9, 2014

In Jeff Horner's 4 Seasons As Valley's Coach, the Tigers Continued a Trend Of Basketball Underachievement. Surely, There's a Coach Out There Who Can Pull Off Some Gary Swenson-Type Magic and Take the High School With All Of Those Students and All Of Those Superb Athletic Facilities To the First State Championship Since 1993




By RON MALY

So Jeff Horner is gone after four seasons and a 70-27 record as the boys' basketball coach at Valley High School. 

So Valley, the huge West Des Moines high
school with all of best and latest facilities--of which so much is expected in athletics, music, drama and everything else--has still seized just one state boys' high school basketball championship, and that was way back in 1993 when Bill Harris was the coach. 

My feeling about what Horner accomplished, or didn't accomplish, at Valley is no doubt somewhat different than that of others. 

I think Horner's four seasons continued a trend of basketball underachievement at Valley. 

Oh, sure, his teams were much better than those produced by Willie Thornton, who preceded him as the Tigers' coach.

But, in my opinion, Horner's four seasons were nothing special. 

His best team should have been the one from two seasons ago, when Peter Jok was a senior. 

But Horner let Jok run his own show. 

Horner was content letting Jok [who knew he was headed to Iowa the following season on a basketball scholarship] take most of the shots, not play defense and not rebound. 

Valley had no inside game, and Jok wasn't the only player who didn't play defense.

No one else did either.

Not surprisingly, the 2013-2014 season was better when Jok was gone.

The Tigers were unspectacular during the regular season, but caught fire in the tournament.

Throughout the regular season, Horner's boys' team played second-fiddle in its own Bill Coldiron Fieldhouse to Joe Sigrist's Tiger girls, who were consistently ranked among the state's top three class 5-A teams.

Valley's girls lost in the first round of the state 5-A tournament to Southeast Polk. The boys finished the season with a 17-9 record and tumbled to Iowa City West, 57-45, in the 4-A state championship game.  

Valley was pretty much a no-show in that game after upsetting No. 1-ranked Dubuque Senior and No. 8 Sioux City North in the earlier rounds. 

The state tournament [at least the first two games of it]  clearly amounted to Horner's finest time as Valley's coach. 

There were plenty of other games in his final season with the Tigers in which his team was outplayed by inferior opponents. 

The bottom line is that Horner is certainly not a master of X's and O's.

Or of motivation. 

Perhaps not discipline either.

For many years, I kept hearing that Valley's best athletes didn't play basketball, choosing instead to participate in Gary Swenson's superb Tiger football program. 

Perhaps that's still somewhat the case. 

Whatever, in my estimation,Valley High School remains a sleeping giant in basketball. 

Athletic director Brad Rose now has a chance to hire someone who will get the most out of the talent available at the school. 

Swenson has won five--count 'em, five--state class 4-A football championships at Valley.

Surely, there's someone out there who can coach the Tigers to their first state basketball championship since 1993.

There will be plenty of interest in the Valley job from outstanding basketball coaches. 

I'm counting on Rose to hire the right guy. 

As for Horner,  I'm guessing he already has a new coaching gig. 

He's smart enough to know that you don't quit at a place like Valley without having a different job.

I wish him well in whatever he does.

And I wish Valley High School well in the 2014-2015 season.